Just Like Grandma Use to Make! Delicious, homemade Italian cuisine

Come dine with us!


Enjoy a taste of Italy

A little off upper Broadway in historic Newburgh, NY, you’ll find Costagliola’s Little Italy, the perfect place to enjoy delectable, authentic Italian home cooking! Gather your family and friends and enjoy an Italian feast like no other! Customers have been known to say our food is “just like grandma used to make.”

Since 1995, we’ve been a family owned and operated business, where every guest is family. At Costagliola’s, we use only the finest and freshest ingredients in everything we make. Enjoy a hot or cold appetizer, generous fresh salads, homemade pastas, chicken, veal, and seafood dinners. We have a vegetarian menu, too! Select a wine from our extensive wine list and your meal is complete.

Enjoy our fine Italian cuisine when you’re having a party or corporate event! We will prepare your favorite dishes in half and full-tray sizes. Our restaurant is available for private parties on Sundays, too! Call us today for more information.

We look forward to serving you and welcoming you to the Costagliola family!